Atha dvitīyaṃ prakaraṇam
Technical Details
atha dvitīyaṃ prakaraṇam|
pūrvamaṣṭavidhā vādadharmā uktāḥ| atha nigraha[sthāna]dharmān vakṣyāmaḥ|
nanu katame vādadharmāḥ| (atrocyate) yathā catvāri mahābhūtāni prajñaptireva| kasmāt| rūpādidharmatvādeva| aparaḥ punarāha| catvāri mahābhūtāni tattvataḥ santi| kathametajjñātam| kāṭhinyaṃ pṛthivīdharmo yāvaccalatvaṃ vāyudharmaḥ| tatsaditi jñeyam| etacca prativiruddham| tasmādvivādaḥ| yathā vā| pṛthivī śarīrakāraṇameva| aparāṇi mahābhūtānyapi tathā| atra dūṣaṇam| pṛthivyādi sarvavastusādhanasamarthaṃ sat, kathaṃ śarīramātraṃ sādhayediti nātra vivādaḥ| yadyevaṃ na syāttadā vāda ityucyate|
nanu kāni nigrahasthānāni| (atrocyate) yathā śabdo nityo'mūrtatvādākāśavat|
atra dūṣaṇam| yadyapi śabdo'mūrtaḥ| tathāpyaindriyakaḥ, saṃpratighaḥ, ghaṭavatkṛtakaḥ| api tvākāśe 'kṛtake kathaṃ tadṛṣṭāntalābhaḥ| etannigrahasthānamityucyate|
atha ghaṭo mūrta ityanityaḥ śabdasya tvamūrtatvāt kathaṃ tadṛṣṭāntalābhaḥ|
atra dūṣaṇam| śabdo ghaṭabhinno'pyaindriyakaḥ śrāvaṇatvāt| tasmādanityaḥ|
nanu kasyārthasyānigrahasthānatvāpattiḥ| saṃskārā vijñānañca kṛtakatvādanityam| nirvāṇamakṛtakatvānnityam| etadvākyaṃ samyakpadarasam| etaducyate 'nigrahasthānam|
nanu kiṃ vacanaṃ dūṣayitavyam| cuayte| vākyavaiparītyaṃ, asaddhetusthāpanaṃ, udāharaṇavaiṣamyañcaitaddūṣayitavyam|
yatha saṃjñā saṃyojanocchedikā, ityukte kaścit pṛcchet| kathaṃ saṃjñā samyojanocchedikā| jñānasya saṃjñāta utpādaṃ pūrvamanutkā saṃjñāmātrakathanādvākyavaiparītyamitīdaṃ dūṣaṇīyam|
nanu kathaṃ punaretadvākyamucyate| asidvasthāpanānnigrahasthānāpattijñāpanārthamuktam|
aparañca| anuyojyānanuyogaḥ| prativaktavye 'prativaktavyata| trirabhihitasya parairavijñātam| trirabhihitasya svayamavijñānam| etāni nigrahasthānāni|
anyacca| pareṇa vivadamānastadvikalatāṃ nāvagacchati| anyastu vadati| eṣo'rthaḥ mithyaiva, kiṃ bhavānnopalabhate tadā nigrahasthānam|
anyacca| parasya samyagarthe doṣasamārope'pi nigrahasthānam|
anyacca| vādinoktaṃ sarvairvijñātamapyasāveva (prativādī) nāvagacchati cettadapi nigrahasthānam| praśno'pi tadvat| etāni nigrahasthānāni vādasya mahākaṇṭakāni gambhīraduḥkhāni jñeyāni, drutañca heyāni|
nanu praśnāḥ katividhāḥ| ucyate| trividhāḥ| yathā vacanasamaḥ, arthasamaḥ, hetusamaśca| yadi vādinastaistribhiḥ praśnottarāṇi na kurvanti tadvibhrāntam| yadyeteṣāṃ trayāṇāmuttarāṇāmanyatamaṃ nyūnaṃ syāttadasampannam|
yadi vadedahamevamprakārān trīn praśnānnāvagacchāmi mama yathājñānamanyonyaṃ praṣṭavyaṃ, tadā'doṣaḥ|
vākyasamaḥ yathā| ātmā nāstītyukte tadvākyāśrayeṇa praśnaḥ| ayaṃ vākyasama ityucyate|
arthasamaḥ tanmatopādānamevāyamarthasama ityucyate|
hetusamaḥ| paramanogaterutpādakasya hetorjñāmayaṃ hetusama ityucyate|
evaṃ sāmarthye satye nigrahasthānamityucyate|
yadyatidrutaṃ vadecchrotāraśca nāvagaccheyustadapi nigrahasthānam|
athaitāvamātramaparāṇi vā santi| atrocyate| santyeva yathā nyūnaṃ, adhikam nirarthakaṃ, aprāptakālaṃ, punaruktaṃ pratijñāsannyāsa ityādīni nigrahasthānānītyucyante|
yadyevamādi pūrvapakṣī vadet, tadā nigrahasthānāpattiḥ|
atha pratijñāvirodhaḥ| yathā vijñānaṃ nityam| kasmāt| vijñānasya hi dvaividhyam| vijñānotpāttirvijñākriyā ca|
ghaṭasyāpi dvaividhyam, ghaṭotpattirghaṭakriyā ca| evaṃ vijñānamutpādyamānameva sakriyaṃ tasmānnityam| ghaṭasya tūtpattyanantaraṃ sakriyatvam, tasmādanityatvam|
atra dūṣaṇam| utpattāveva sakriyatvānnityamiti ceddīpasyāpyutpattāveva sakriyatvānnityatvaprasaṅgaḥ| atha dīpaścakṣuṣā dṛṣṭaḥ syāt, śabdaśca śravaṇena śrūyata iti kathaṃ dṛṣṭāntopapattiḥ| etatpratijñāsannyāsanigrahasthānam|
aparañca| kecidvadantyātmā nitya iti| kathaṃ jñātam| anaindriyakatvāt| yathā ākāśo'naindriyakatvānnityaḥ|
atra dūṣaṇam| paramāṇavo'nindriyakā api tvanityāḥ|
atrocyate| ātmā'kṛtakatvānnityaḥ paramāṇavastu kṛtakatvādanityāḥ|
atra dūṣaṇam| anupalabdheriti bhavatā pūrvamuktam| adhunā cākṛtakatvādibyucyate| ayaṃ pratijñāvirodhaḥ|
nanūcyate 'haṃ virodhīti cebhdavāṃstu mama vacanaṃ pratikūlayan katham virodhau na syāt|
kiñca kathametadyuktisaham| yadvi viruddhamityucyate mayā, sā bhavata eva vacanasya pūrvoktenārthan pratikūlatā| tasmādviruddhamityuktam|
anyacca| bhavatā pūrvamuktamaspaṣṭatvānme saṃśaya utpanna iti| nāhaṃ bhavadvirodhītyevaṃ saṃśayena virodhaḥ| etadapi nigrahasthānamiti|
||iti dvitīyaṃ prakaraṇam||